جملة معترض علي حلها

[الأستاذ نادي ربيع]

المشاركة الأصلية كتبت بواسطة ali ahmed 3

me too I think both of them are correct
if we regarded school as a building ,we can use'where'
but if we rgarded school as a curriculum=course I think we can use 'which'
(the same with the word( class)

اتفق مع الزميل العزيز
و ان كنت اميل اكثر الى where
و يمكن استخدام which فى حالة وجود حرف الجر in

[taraweesh]

The correct answer is "Which" because the verb attend is followed by the place without preposition.
I attend school. correct
I attend in school. incorrect
the relative pronoun "where" must replace a place adverb not an object. In other words the pronoun where replaces a preposition + noun or the word "there"

[ancient mariner]

the best answer for this sentence is
The school which I attended
because teh question doesn't talk about school as a place here

[Egyknight]

المشاركة الأصلية كتبت بواسطة نبيل موريس جورج

لو سمحتم أريد رد كل اساتذة المنتدي علي هذه الجملة
The school (which / where) I attended has only one classroom.

The original two sentences are:
The school has one classroom . I attended in it .
where refers to the place I attend in it
but if we regard to school as a course. the classroom is a place and doesn't`keep in step with a course.
SO
The best answer is (Where)

[Mr Saber Aboziad Abd Elma]

I think the best answer is of course
{ where } because we refer to it as aplace when we say has one class

[taraweesh]

يا حونا attend لايأتى بعدها حرف جر أبدا
I can't say "attend in school

[ايمن ابو كريم المنياوى]

In my opinion the best answer to this sentence is which not wheras we
don't use preposition with attend

[ezzatmina]

I think that the correct answer should b" which I attend Because school here i referred to as a thing like a course it is not refered to a s a place .What makes this opinion more probable is using the verb attend not go

[محمود مان]

الادق where لان الجملة تتحدث عن المدرسة المكان

[ahmed.nabil155]

The answer is where because it describes the place I attend in it definitely

[نبيل موريس جورج]

شاكر للجميع علي المررو ولكن اعتقد الاجابة which هي الاجابة الصحيحة

[kh2mh]

which هي الاجابة الصحيحة

[abdrabu62]

Dear Mr. Nabil
I think the correct answer is WHICH not where
In your example "SCHOOL" is the direct object of the verb ATTEND
We say: attend the funeral / class / a meeting ....etc.
We also say: Which school do your children attend? -
- The school which my children attend is called Al Fustat
Here is An Easy Test to decide whether to use WHICH or WHERE
Use the word replaced by the relative pronoun after the verb that comes after it
1. If that word requires an adverb particle "e.g. in, on, at, under, below ....etc. before it, then it refers to place or position. In this case we must use WHERE
Example
The place (which / where) he was born is Tanta.
Note: He was born in this place./ in Tanta / in it
Here the correct answer is "WHERE"
2. If that word does not require an adverb particle, it is a direct object of the verb preceding it. In this case we have to use WHICH
Example
The place (which / where) we visited last week was fascinating
Note: We visited that place. We visited it
In this case we are using `place` as mere object. So we must use "WHICH or THAT"
BEST REGARDS

[Sw0rdD]

The right answer is beyond doubt 'which'. If you are not sure look in the following link
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/The_school...chill_attended

[mahmoud_sagan]

The answer is where